How to Tie the Film Critic
| Part | Material |
|---|---|
| Hook | Tiemco 2487 #14-18 |
| Thread | Nanosilk 18/0 dark brown |
| Tail | wood duck or gold mallard flank fibers |
| Shuck | copper or brown Antron yarn |
| Rib | fine copper wire |
| Body | grey olive Superfine dubbing (match the hatch) |
| Wing | dun poly yarn |
| Hackle | blue dun rooster cape or saddle |
| Thorax | grey olive Superfine dubbing (match the hatch) |
Step-by-Step Instructions
- 1
Thread Base
Set the Tiemco 2487 in the vise with the eye tipped down a little so the bend is exposed. Start the 18/0 Nanosilk and wrap back about halfway down the bend.
- 2
Shuck Tail
Tie in a sparse clump of wood duck gold mallard flank at the bend with the fibers' curve facing down. Wrap forward over the butts a little past halfway and clip them.
- 3
Shuck Thorax
Tie a very sparse clump of copper or brown Antron (about a fifth of a strand) in at the front and wrap back over it to the base of the mallard tail to keep the underbody even. Cut it short there so it forms the hump of the empty nymphal shuck.
- 4
Rib
Tie in fine copper wire, wrapping over it back to the base of the shuck.
- 5
Abdomen
Dub a thin strand of grey olive Superfine from the bend forward with a slight taper, stopping a little short of the thorax.
- 6
Rib Forward
Spiral the copper wire forward through the abdomen, tie it off at the front with a few turns and break off the excess.
- 7
Wing Post
Tie a piece of dun poly yarn in by one end on top at the front edge of the abdomen. Run the thread to the eye and back, tie the yarn down again and cut the butt, giving a smooth underbody for the thorax. A single parachute wrap at the base of the yarn can help stand it up.
- 8
Tie In Hackle
Size a blue dun hackle so its fibers reach back to the bend when measured around the post. Strip a few fibers at the base and trim the rest short so the stem has little teeth. Tie it in on the near side with the concave side down toward the hook and wrap over the stem to the base of the wing.
- 9
Stack the Hackle
Hold the yarn straight up with hackle pliers. Wrap the hackle up the yarn about as far as the distance to the hook eye, then back down through the turns you just made, keeping it deliberately messy. Pull the feather toward you at the base, tie off the tip and trim it.
- 10
Thorax
Hold the hackle back and dub a thorax of the same grey olive Superfine up to the base of the wing, rounding it out, and leave at least an eye length of bare shank behind the eye.
- 11
Fold the Hackle Over
Fold the hackle off what will become the underside of the post, then pull the yarn and hackle forward over the thorax and catch them behind the eye with a pinch wrap. Pull on the thread and the wing together to draw them down tight, so the hackle becomes a wingcase over the top of the fly.
- 12
Finish
Sweep everything up and back, build a few thread turns in front to stand the front of the wing up slightly, and whip finish behind the eye. Cut the wing at a slight angle to about a shank length.
How to Fish the Film Critic
Fish the Film Critic in the film or just below the surface during mayfly hatches, particularly effective when trout are feeding selectively on emergers. The pattern works best when fished dead drift in slow currents where part of the fly rides below the surface film and part above, simulating a mayfly half-emerging. Use sizes #10-12 for Green Drakes, #12-14 for Gray Drakes, and #14-16 for smaller patterns. Most effective during spring and summer when large mayfly activity peaks, especially on spring creeks and tailwaters. The pattern excels in selective situations when trout refuse traditional dry flies. The subtle movements and half-trapped look often provoke strikes. Works exceptionally well in pressured fisheries where trout are selective. Match colors to specific hatches: olive for Green Drakes, gray for Gray Drakes, brown for Brown Drakes.




